Sign up for Autoship by 1/15 & save BIG on first three orders, see terms* >

  • $0 - $50+

    $0$25$50+

Comforting Toys

(14 results)
Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Squirrel Flattie Dog Toy - Crinkle, Squeaker

Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Squirrel Flattie Dog Toy - Crinkle, Squeaker

(390)
$9.99
10X points (20% back in savings) on ALL Dog and Cat Toys
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Duck Dog Toy - Plush, Squeaker

Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Duck Dog Toy - Plush, Squeaker

(266)
$9.99
10X points (20% back in savings) on ALL Dog and Cat Toys
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Rabbit Flattie Dog Toy - Crinkle, Squeaker

Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Rabbit Flattie Dog Toy - Crinkle, Squeaker

(203)
$13.99
10X points (20% back in savings) on ALL Dog and Cat Toys
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Bite Shield™ Protection Plush Crocodile Dog Toy - Squeaker, Crinkle

Joyhound® Bite Shield™ Protection Plush Crocodile Dog Toy - Squeaker, Crinkle

(174)
$19.99
10X points (20% back in savings) on ALL Dog and Cat Toys
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Raccoon Flattie Dog Toy - Crinkle, Squeaker

Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Raccoon Flattie Dog Toy - Crinkle, Squeaker

(186)
$13.99
10X points (20% back in savings) on ALL Dog and Cat Toys
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Squirrel Dog Toy - Plush, Squirrel

Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Squirrel Dog Toy - Plush, Squirrel

(162)
$9.99
10X points (20% back in savings) on ALL Dog and Cat Toys
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Rabbit Dog Toy - Plush, Squeaker

Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Rabbit Dog Toy - Plush, Squeaker

(194)
$9.99
10X points (20% back in savings) on ALL Dog and Cat Toys
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Bite Shield™ Protection Plush Octopus Dog Toy - Squeaker, Crinkle

Joyhound® Bite Shield™ Protection Plush Octopus Dog Toy - Squeaker, Crinkle

(214)
$19.99
10X points (20% back in savings) on ALL Dog and Cat Toys
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Bite Shield™ Protection Plush Sting Ray Dog Toy - Squeaker, Crinkle

Joyhound® Bite Shield™ Protection Plush Sting Ray Dog Toy - Squeaker, Crinkle

(210)
$14.99
10X points (20% back in savings) on ALL Dog and Cat Toys
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Fox Flattie Dog Toy - Crinkle, Squeaker

Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Fox Flattie Dog Toy - Crinkle, Squeaker

(261)
$9.99
10X points (20% back in savings) on ALL Dog and Cat Toys
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Plush Giraffe & Lion Dog Toy - 2 Pack, Squeaker

Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Plush Giraffe & Lion Dog Toy - 2 Pack, Squeaker

(110)
$11.99
10X points (20% back in savings) on ALL Dog and Cat Toys
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Pheasant Dog Toy - Plush, Squeaker

Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Pheasant Dog Toy - Plush, Squeaker

(230)
$13.99
10X points (20% back in savings) on ALL Dog and Cat Toys
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Plush Crocodile & Monkey Dog Toy - 2 Pack, Squeaker

Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Plush Crocodile & Monkey Dog Toy - 2 Pack, Squeaker

(83)
$11.99
10X points (20% back in savings) on ALL Dog and Cat Toys
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Realistic Binded Mallard Duck Dog Toy - Plush, Squeaker

Joyhound® Realistic Binded Mallard Duck Dog Toy - Plush, Squeaker

(116)
$13.99
10X points (20% back in savings) on ALL Dog and Cat Toys
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
  1. 1
Legit ScriptDot Pharmacy
Download on the App StoreDownload on the Google Play Store
Copyright © 2026 Petsmart LLC
RecallsTerms of UsePrivacy PolicyInterest-Based AdsCA Supply Chain ActCA Privacy RightsYour Privacy ChoicesPrivacy Icon
*See Promotional Terms Page for details. Exclusions may apply. While supplies last. Prices & selection may vary by store & online.