Plush, Balls & Mice

(165 results)
@Multipet Duckworth Assorted Catnip Filled Cat Toy 4 IN
(10)
$3.99
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
Whisker City® Pickle Cat Toy - Catnip, Plush
(333)
$2.99
Save 35% On Your First Autoship Order!
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Whisker City® Spring Toys Cat Toys - 4 Pack
(227)
$4.99
Save 35% On Your First Autoship Order!
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Multipet Rainbow Caterpillar Catnip Cat Toy
(63)
$2.00
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
Instincts SmartyKat Catnip Caravan Cat Toy - 3 Pack
(87)
$5.99
$7.99
Save 35% On Your First Autoship Order!
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Catstages Crunchy Catnip Pickle Cat Toy
(168)
$5.59
$9.99
Save 35% On Your First Autoship Order!
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Catstages Dental Banana Teether Cat Toy
(77)
$4.99
$5.99
Save 35% On Your First Autoship Order!
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Whisker City® Tinsel Balls Cat Toys - 4 Pack (COLOR VARIES)
(306)
$4.99
Save 35% On Your First Autoship Order!
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
SmartyKat Skitter Slices Catnip Mice Cat Toys
(84)
$0.99
$1.99
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
Whisker City Lizard Cat Toy
(15)
$2.00
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
Whisker City® Crinkle Ball Cat Toy - (COLOR VARIES)
(132)
$1.99
Save 35% On Your First Autoship Order!
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Whisker City® Fun Ball Cat Toys - 6 Pack (COLOR VARIES)
(130)
$7.99
Save 35% On Your First Autoship Order!
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Whisker City® Fluff Balls Cat Toys - 3 Pack
(202)
$6.99
Save 35% On Your First Autoship Order!
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Hello Kitty Cupcake Plush Catnip Cat Toy 2-Pack
(2)
$4.97
$9.99
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
 Lamb Chop Head Bell Catnip Cat toy
(4)
$2.99
$3.99
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
Woodstock-inspired Stuffed Cat Toy
(6)
$3.99
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
Whisker City® Wool Mice Cat Toys - 6 Pack
(130)
$7.99
Save 35% On Your First Autoship Order!
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Whisker City® Chirping Bird Cat Toy
(204)
$6.99
Save 35% On Your First Autoship Order!
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Whisker City® Sparkle Fish & Feathers Cat Toys - 2 Pack
(50)
$5.99
Save 35% On Your First Autoship Order!
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Catstages Fresh Breath Mint Stick Cat Toy
(142)
$2.99
$5.99
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
Catstages Catnip Chew Mice Cat Toy
(48)
$3.99
$7.99
Save 35% On Your First Autoship Order!
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Hello Kitty and Friends Keroppi and Lily Pad Plush Crinkle Catnip Cat Toy 2-Pack
(0)
$6.97
$9.99
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
Hello Kitty Ball Cat Toy 4-Pack
(0)
$13.97
$16.99
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
Hello Kitty and Friends Pompompurin Plush Cat Toy 2-Pack
(0)
$6.97
$9.99
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
 Hello Kitty Mice Plush 2-Pack Cat Toy
(2)
$7.97
$9.99
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
Whisker City® Kicker Cat Toy
(6)
$8.99
Save 35% On Your First Autoship Order!
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Instincts SmartyKat Fin Frenzy Kicker Cat Toy
(74)
$6.99
$10.99
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
Whisker City® Cafe Breakfast Cat Toy - 3 Pack
(10)
$7.99
Save 35% On Your First Autoship Order!
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Whisker City® X-Large Hammerhead Kicker Cat Toy - Catnip
(72)
$7.99
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
Whisker City® "No Touchy The Kitty Toys" Toy Basket
(124)
$14.99
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
Whisker City® "Home Is Where The Cat Is" Toy Basket
(90)
$14.99
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
Whisker City® Squid Kicker Cat Toy
(116)
$8.99
Save 35% On Your First Autoship Order!
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Whisker City® Safari Feather Ball Cat Toys - 2 Pack
(98)
$5.99
Save 35% On Your First Autoship Order!
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Whisker City® Mice Cat Toys - 10 Pack (COLOR VARIES)
(80)
$9.99
Save 35% On Your First Autoship Order!
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Catstages Magic Dynamite Cat Toy
(98)
$5.99
$9.99
Save 35% On Your First Autoship Order!
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
+ 1 more
Mad Cat Silvernip Porky Cat Toy
(2)
$0.97
$2.00
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
Whisker City Plush Fish Cat Toy
(7)
$2.00
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
Multipet Assorted Colors Rattle Cat Toy
(8)
$2.00
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
Whisker City Plush Snake Cat Toy
(16)
$2.00
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
Whisker City® Fuzzy Friend Ball Cat Toy
(16)
$1.99
Free Same-Day Delivery, No Order Minimum!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
Finding your kitten’s favorite toy is a great way to get to know their personality and encourages bonding between you and your cat. Whether your feline friend is a cuddler, a stalker or just likes to play, our collection of plush cat toys and stuffed animals will give them hours of fun. Shop our selection of realistic stuffed animals for cats with faux fur to sturdy teethers and cuddlers at PetSmart. They'll love to snuggle with faux-fur mice that are perfect for stalking, battle with teasers and wrestle with toys on a daily basis. Browse our collection and give your cat the stuffed animal toys they need to stay active and engaged.
Does your cat have a different favorite toy? Aside from stuffed animals for cats, PetSmart carries a wide variety of other cat and kitten toys, such as:
For even more fun, try out new cat toys or stock up on the ones they already love with PetSmart’s toy multi-packs
Need something besides plush cat toys? Check out PetSmart’s selection of the best cat supplies, including cat foodlittertreats, and more. We carry products from trusted brands at great prices so you can help your kitty live their best life.
PetSmart also offers convenient shopping with curbside or in-store pickup. Need something today? We have select items available for same-day delivery in most areas powered by DoorDash. For items you purchase frequently, PetSmart has Autoship that automatically delivers the items you want to your door as often as you’d like. Check the website to see which items are eligible.