EXTRA 20% OFF thousands of pet faves online with code: SAVE20 thru 5/15* >

  • $0 - $50+

    $0$25$50+

Savings In The Nick Of Time

(35 results)
Oxbow Western Timothy Hay
6 sizes

Oxbow Western Timothy Hay

(1724)
$5.48 - $84.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 2 more
Oxbow Western Timothy & Orchard Grass Hay
3 sizes

Oxbow Western Timothy & Orchard Grass Hay

(414)
$5.94 - $22.09
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 2 more
Full Cheeks™ Natural Timothy Hay
4 sizes

Full Cheeksâ„¢ Natural Timothy Hay

(667)
$4.99 - $25.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 2 more
KAYTEE® All Natural Timothy Hay
3 sizes

KAYTEE® All Natural Timothy Hay

(715)
$5.99 - $17.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 2 more
Oxbow Orchard Grass
3 sizes

Oxbow Orchard Grass

(360)
$5.52 - $25.49
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 2 more
Oxbow Alfalfa Hay
3 sizes

Oxbow Alfalfa Hay

(116)
$5.52 - $25.49
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 2 more
Full Cheeks™ Natural Orchard Hay

Full Cheeksâ„¢ Natural Orchard Hay

(18)
$9.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 2 more
Oxbow Foraging Hay Blend Teff & Western Timothy Hay

Oxbow Foraging Hay Blend Teff & Western Timothy Hay

(0)
$12.32
$14.49
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
Full Cheeks™ Timothy Hay With Peas and Carrots

Full Cheeksâ„¢ Timothy Hay With Peas and Carrots

(110)
$14.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 2 more
Small Pet Select 2nd Cut Timothy Hay
5 sizes

Small Pet Select 2nd Cut Timothy Hay

(1287)
$16.49 - $89.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
Full Cheeks™ Natural Alfalfa Hay

Full Cheeksâ„¢ Natural Alfalfa Hay

(8)
$9.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 2 more
Small Pet Select Orchard Hay
2 sizes

Small Pet Select Orchard Hay

(521)
$34.99 - $54.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
Oxbow Botanical Hay

Oxbow Botanical Hay

(10)
$5.52
$6.49
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
Field+Forest by Kaytee Mini Hay Bale - 1pk
2 flavors

Field+Forest by Kaytee Mini Hay Bale - 1pk

(260)
$6.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 2 more
Small Pet Select White Paper Bedding
2 sizes

Small Pet Select White Paper Bedding

(99)
$22.99 - $45.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
Small Pet Select 1st Cut Timothy Hay
2 sizes

Small Pet Select 1st Cut Timothy Hay

(380)
$34.99 - $54.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
Full Cheeks™ Timothy Hay with Apple and Banana

Full Cheeksâ„¢ Timothy Hay with Apple and Banana

(100)
$14.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 2 more
Oxbow Harvest Stack Western Timothy Hay

Oxbow Harvest Stack Western Timothy Hay

(64)
$11.59
$11.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 2 more
Small Pet Select Straight Timothy Hay Cubes
2 sizes

Small Pet Select Straight Timothy Hay Cubes

(173)
$7.99 - $19.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
Small Pet Select Orchard Hay

Small Pet Select Orchard Hay

(518)
$16.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
Small Pet Select 1st Cut Timothy Hay Small Pet Food
2 sizes

Small Pet Select 1st Cut Timothy Hay Small Pet Food

(381)
$16.99 - $94.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
Small Pet Select 3rd Cutting Timothy Small Pet Hay
2 sizes

Small Pet Select 3rd Cutting Timothy Small Pet Hay

(328)
$12.99 - $99.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
Small Pet Select Premium Ultra Soft Timothy Hay

Small Pet Select Premium Ultra Soft Timothy Hay

(149)
$12.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
Small Pet Select 2nd Cutting Perfect Blend Timoithy Hay

Small Pet Select 2nd Cutting Perfect Blend Timoithy Hay

(1256)
$26.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
Small Pet Select 3rd Cut Timothy Hay
2 sizes

Small Pet Select 3rd Cut Timothy Hay

(280)
$36.99 - $59.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
Small Pet Select Sampler Hay Box

Small Pet Select Sampler Hay Box

(180)
$42.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
Small Pet Select Value Choice Timothy Hay

Small Pet Select Value Choice Timothy Hay

(115)
$19.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
Oxbow Oat Hay

Oxbow Oat Hay

(15)
$5.52
$6.49
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
Field+Forest by Kaytee Mini Hay Bales - 2pk
2 flavors

Field+Forest by Kaytee Mini Hay Bales - 2pk

(248)
$12.95
$14.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
KAYTEE® Wafer Cut Timothy Hay

KAYTEE® Wafer Cut Timothy Hay

(6)
$13.95
$16.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
KAYTEE® All Natural Alfalfa Hay Cubes

KAYTEE® All Natural Alfalfa Hay Cubes

(46)
$2.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
Brown's® Tropical Carnival® Timothy Hay
2 sizes

Brown's® Tropical Carnival® Timothy Hay

(100)
$7.99 - $14.79
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
Brown's® Tropical Carnival® Play Barn with Timothy Hay

Brown's® Tropical Carnival® Play Barn with Timothy Hay

(4)
$10.59
$14.19
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
KAYTEE® All Natural Timothy Hay Plus Carrot

KAYTEE® All Natural Timothy Hay Plus Carrot

(42)
$8.95
$10.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
KAYTEE® All Natural Alfalfa Hay Mini Bale

KAYTEE® All Natural Alfalfa Hay Mini Bale

(40)
$5.99
35% off first order with Autoship
Buy 1, Get the 2nd 50% OFF Small Pet Bedding, Hay, Treats, & Chews - Online Only
Earn 5X points (10% back in savings) on all small pet products!
+ 1 more
  1. 1
Legit ScriptDot Pharmacy
Download on the App StoreDownload on the Google Play Store
Copyright © 2026 Petsmart LLC
RecallsTerms of UsePrivacy PolicyInterest-Based AdsCA Supply Chain ActCA Privacy Rights
*See Promotional Terms Page for details. Exclusions may apply. While supplies last. Prices & selection may vary by store & online.