Time to start shopping!
Plush Toys
sort by
Best Sellers
-
Whisker City® Pickle Cat Toy - Catnip, Plush
Discounted Price $2.79 Old Price $2.99
Save 15% With Buy Online, Pickup in Store or Curbside Pickup!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
-
KONG® Refillables Turtle Cat Toy - Catnip
Discounted Price $2.99 Old Price $5.99
Save 15% With Buy Online, Pickup in Store or Curbside Pickup!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
-
KONG® Refillables Squirrel Cat Toy - Catnip
Discounted Price $3.99 Old Price $5.99
Save 15% With Buy Online, Pickup in Store or Curbside Pickup!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
-
Petlinks® Lil Creepers™ Mice Cat Toys - 3 Pack
Discounted Price $3.59 Old Price $15.49
Save 15% With Buy Online, Pickup in Store or Curbside Pickup!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
-
Petstages® Purr Pillow Cat Toy
Discounted Price $11.99 Old Price $14.99
Save 15% With Buy Online, Pickup in Store or Curbside Pickup!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
-
Petstages® Dental Banana Teether Cat Toy
Discounted Price $3.99 Old Price $4.99
Save 15% With Buy Online, Pickup in Store or Curbside Pickup!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
-
KONG® Kickeroo™ Cuddler Cat Toy (COLOR VARIES)
Discounted Price $4.59 Old Price $7.29
Save 15% With Buy Online, Pickup in Store or Curbside Pickup!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
-
Petstages® Kitty Cuddle Pal Cat Toy
Discounted Price $8.79 Old Price $10.99
Save 15% With Buy Online, Pickup in Store or Curbside Pickup!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
-
Petstages® Nighttime Cuddle Cat Toy
Discounted Price $5.59 Old Price $6.99
Save 15% With Buy Online, Pickup in Store or Curbside Pickup!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
-
Petstages® Magic Dynamite Cat Toy
Discounted Price $6.39 Old Price $7.99
Save 15% With Buy Online, Pickup in Store or Curbside Pickup!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
-
Meowijuana® Catnip Cigar Cat Toy - Plush (COLOR VARIES)
Discounted Price $8.99 Old Price $12.99
Save 15% With Buy Online, Pickup in Store or Curbside Pickup!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
-
Petlinks® HappyNip™ Cutie Bandit™ Flying Racoon Cat Toy - Catnip
Discounted Price $5.99 Old Price $7.99
Save 15% With Buy Online, Pickup in Store or Curbside Pickup!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
-
Petlinks® Refillable Mouse Cat Toy - Catnip
Discounted Price $8.99 Old Price $14.99
Save 15% With Buy Online, Pickup in Store or Curbside Pickup!
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
-
Petlinks® HappyNip™ Mohawk Mice™ Cat Toys - 2 Pack
Discounted Price $4.99 Old Price $5.99
Save 15% With Buy Online, Pickup in Store or Curbside Pickup!
-
Top Paw® Ostrich Dog Toy - Crinkle, Plush, Squeaker
Discounted Price $2.50 Old Price $7.59
-
Whisker City® Angel Fish Cat Toy - Catnip, Light-Up
Discounted Price $1.00 Old Price $5.99
-
OurPets® Jose Pedro™ Play-N-Squeak® Cactus Cat Toy - Plush, Squeaker
Discounted Price $1.00 Old Price $6.99
-
Whisker City® Chirping & Wobbling Parrot Pineapple Cat Toy - Catnip
Discounted Price $1.57 Old Price $5.99
-
OurPets® Mr. Narwhal™ Play-N-Squeak® Cat Toy - Plush, Squeaker
Discounted Price $1.00 Old Price $6.99
-
KONG® Enchanted Buzzy Unicorn Cat Toy - Catnip, Plush
Discounted Price $1.00 Old Price $6.99
-
KONG® Softies Frizz™ Bird Cat Toy - Catnip (COLOR VARIES)
Discounted Price $1.00 Old Price $5.99
-
Petstages® Daisy Chew Wheel Cat Toy
Discounted Price $3.19 Old Price $4.09
-
Jackson Galaxy® Ultimate Bunny Kicker™ Cat Toy
Discounted Price $8.95 Old Price $11.99
-
Jackson Galaxy® Hunting Instincts Kicker Cat Toy
Discounted Price $8.95 Old Price $11.99
-
OurPets® Squeaky Treat Cat Toy Treat Ball
Discounted Price $2.50 Old Price $6.99
-
Jackson Galaxy® Mixed Twisted Kicker Cat Toy - Catnip
Discounted Price $5.95 Old Price $8.59
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping Over $49
-
Jackson Galaxy® Mixed Twisted Refillable Kicker Cat Toy
Discounted Price $2.50 Old Price $10.99
-
Petlinks® Tea Zing Tea Bag Cat Toys - 3 Pack
Discounted Price $2.50 Old Price $7.99
