Plush Toys
134 Items Available
-
On Sale
Exclusive
ToyShoppe® Plush Flying Squirrel Cat Toy
Our Price:
$2.99
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
On Sale
KONG® Kickeroo™ Wrestling Catnip Toys
Price:
was $7.99
now: $6.39Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
On Sale
KONG® Cats With An Attitude Squirrel Catnip Toy
Price:
was $5.49
now: $4.39Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
On Sale
Exclusive
Whisker City® Catnip Puffs
Price:
was $4.49
now: $3.36Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Petstages Kitty Cuddle Pal Cat Toy
Our Price:
$4.77
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
On Sale
Exclusive
ToyShoppe® Look Who's Talking Frog
Price:
was $3.99
now: $2.99Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
On Sale
Exclusive
Martha Stewart Pets™ Assorted Plush Starfish
Price:
was $5.99
now: $4.79Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
KONG® for Cats Kitten Teddy Bear
Our Price:
$5.49
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
On Sale
Exclusive
Martha Stewart Pets™ Angler Floss Toy
Price:
was $4.99
now: $3.99Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Laurel Burch™ Refillable Catnip Kickeroo
Our Price:
$2.77
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Exclusive
ToyShoppe® Squeaking Bird
Our Price:
$4.99
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
KONG® Softies™ Patchwork Bear
Our Price:
$6.99
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Online Only
Petmate Big Batters Cat Toys
Our Price:
$6.99
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
On Sale
Laurel Burch® Multi Petal Large Cat Toy
Our Price:
$6.97
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
On Sale
Exclusive
Martha Stewart Pets™ Plush Seahorse
Price:
was $5.99
now: $4.79Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
KONG® Naturals Crinkle Fish with Feathers Cat Toys
Our Price:
$5.99
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
On Sale
Exclusive
ToyShoppe® Feathered Bird Cat Toy
Price:
was $3.99
now: $2.99Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
On Sale
Exclusive
Martha Stewart Pets™ Patchwork Flamingo
Price:
was $3.99
now: $3.19Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Petlinks® Finger Wings™ Bouncy Interactive Cat Toy
Our Price:
$3.47
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Exclusive
Grreat Choice™ Plush Bird Cat Toy
Our Price:
$2.37
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
On Sale
KONG® Refillable Catnip Toys
Price:
was $5.49
now: $4.39Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Exclusive
Grreat Choice™ Plush Turtle Cat Toy
Our Price:
$2.37
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Exclusive
Grreat Choice™ Plush Fish Cat Toy
Our Price:
$2.97
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
KONG® for Cats Denim Kickaroo™ Toy
Our Price:
$7.99
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
On Sale
Exclusive
ToysRUs® Catnip Filled Animal Cat Toys
Price:
was $2.99
now: $2.39Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Exclusive
ToyShoppe® Plush Owl Cat Toy
Our Price:
$2.99
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
On Sale
Exclusive
Grreat Choice Plush w/Feathered Tail
Price:
was $2.99
now: $2.54Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Exclusive
ToyShoppe® Feathered Bird Cat Toy
Our Price:
$2.77
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Exclusive
Grreat Choice™ Sheep Skin Catnip Mouse
Our Price:
$1.49
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Laurel Burch® Fish Kicker Cat Toy
Our Price:
$4.17
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Petlinks® System Crazy Tail™ Spinning String Cat Toy
Our Price:
$19.99
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
KONG® Cat Fuzzy Ball Cat Toy
Our Price:
$9.99
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Exclusive
Martha Stewart Pets™ Cigar Mouse Cat Toy
Our Price:
$4.99
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
On Sale
Exclusive
Grreat Choice™ Short Hair Mouse
Price:
was $8.99
now: $7.19Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Exclusive
Martha Stewart Pets™ Mouse in Cheese
Our Price:
$5.99
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Laurel Burch® Cat Face w/ Wings Cat Toy
Our Price:
$4.87
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Exclusive
ToyShoppe® Plush River Fish Cat Toys
Our Price:
$5.49
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
On Sale
KONG® Rat Refillable Catnip Toy
Price:
was $5.49
now: $4.39Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
On Sale
KONG® Refillable Catnip Toys
Price:
was $5.49
now: $4.39Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Laurel Burch® Cat Face Roller Cat Toy
Our Price:
$4.17
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Petlinks® Tackle Twist™ Catnip Kick Toy for Cats
Our Price:
$7.99
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
On Sale
Exclusive
ToysRUs® Rainbow Plush Snail/Lizard Cat Toys
Price:
was $3.99
now: $3.19Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Exclusive
ToyShoppe® Animal Print Balls
Our Price:
$0.99
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
On Sale
Exclusive
Martha Stewart Pets™ Assorted Furry Mice
Price:
was $5.99
now: $4.79Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
KONG® BraidZ Safari Catnip Toy
Our Price:
$2.97
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
On Sale
Laurel Burch® Butterfly Catnip Cat Toy
Our Price:
$4.17
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Exclusive
ToyShoppe® Motion Critter Cat Toy
Our Price:
$1.17
Free Shipping on orders over $75**
-
Exclusive
Grreat Choice™ Crinkle Bugs Cat Toy
Our Price:
$0.97
